Defining and managing scope is one of the hardest things to get right in a contract, and one of the biggest sources of value leakage when it goes wrong. I grapple with it on every project.
There is never just one way to do things. So rather than put forward a single scope and price, I now try to offer options at different price points. It quickly shows where the value really lies for the customer.
With technology evolving so fast, contracting for inputs, whether hours or deliverables, makes less and less sense. But contracting for outcomes is hard too, because what's possible keeps expanding. How can a contract deliver value today and leave room for more tomorrow?
When scope isn't managed well, both sides end up feeling shortchanged. The customer pays more than expected for less than they hoped. The supplier has done more than it was paid for, yet created less value than it could have. And because the contract measures inputs and makes variation hard, the better answer goes to the next customer instead.
I've seen this throughout my legal career and still see it now, which is why I wrote the article below for World Commerce & Contracting's Contracting Excellence Journal.
This article was first published by World Commerce & Contracting in the Contracting Excellence Journal on 1 October 2026. You can read the original on the WorldCC website.
Ask a room full of supply-side contract managers about scope creep, and you get a consistent story. The customer asks for more than was agreed. The supplier does it, because the relationship matters and each request seems small. Multiply that by a hundred small requests and the profit margin is gone.
Ask a room of buyers, and you get the mirror image: costs that crept up, variations that arrived late, and a final number nobody expected.
The leakage runs both ways.
WorldCC’s 2026 report with Ironclad, Closing the Procurement Value Gap1, puts average value leakage at 11% of contract value. That 11% is not one big failure. It breaks into seven categories, and unauthorised or unrecorded changes - scope creep, in plain language - account for 2–3% of it.
So scope creep is real, expensive, and roughly a quarter of the problem.
What’s striking is what sits beside it at the same weight. Missed savings from poor negotiation: 2–3%. Renewal costs from poor forward planning: 2–3%. Then four more at 1–2% each: unrealised benefits from unmanaged clauses, overpayment from untracked price adjustments, penalties and disputes from missed obligations, and relationship damage and lost innovation.
If your entire response to value leakage is a tighter change-control process, you have addressed a quarter of it while leaving the rest running.
Scope Seep, the leak nobody raises a variation for
There’s a second flow in the same channel, running the other way.
Suppliers routinely deliver more than they are paid for, on their own initiative, because they can see a better answer than the one specified. The customer never asked. No variation was raised. The extra value simply arrives, unpriced and unacknowledged. Call it scope seep - that’s my label (borrowed from my friend, John Chisholm), not WorldCC’s - but it happens a lot with professionals who are uncomfortable delivering anything but their very best work even when the client was happy with something less.
The innovation that never happened because the scope didn't change
This may be the biggest leak of all. WorldCC’s 2019 study Supplier-Led Innovation and Continuous Improvement2 found that 79% of contracts include innovation or continuous improvement terms, but 70% of respondents said those terms are frequently ineffective. Half of clients said they define what innovation actually means in their contract. Only 28% of suppliers agreed. And this is the stinger: half the suppliers surveyed said they had held back from proposing an innovation or improvement due to a lack of incentives or customer openness.
That is not a drafting failure. It is a design failure. If an innovation reduces scope or cost, the service provider ends up with a lower fee. If it increases value for the customer without benefiting the supplier, that doesn’t feel fair. The provider has little or no incentive to put the idea forward. They may offer it to new customers instead, under a new contract, which is the opposite of how a good relationship should grow.
The same report shows how little infrastructure exists to catch these ideas even when they are offered: 32% of clients claim a formal structure for evaluating supplier initiatives, only 15% of suppliers agree, and more than 40% of suppliers say they have never encountered a client who has one.
In the 2026 report, this shows up as its own leakage categories:
- Unrealised benefits from unmanaged clauses, at 1–2%. Innovation commitments, continuous improvement mechanisms, gain-share arrangements, and volume discounts that were negotiated but never activated. It was agreed, written down, and left in the drawer.
- relationship damage and lost innovation, also at 1-2%. Adversarial behaviours that discourage suppliers from bringing forward ideas, talent and investment.
These are smaller than scope creep and, arguably, more galling because nobody took that value.
I would argue that if the relationship is as good as it could be, you don’t need clauses in a contract to force these conversations. They should be happening naturally, all the time. For these reasons, I think 2–4% leakage is likely on the low side.
Outcomes - the frame that will matter most from here
Most contracts price scope of effort. Days, resources, deliverables, hours. However, what the customer is buying is scope of outcome. In knowledge work, and in anything powered by technology, those two have come apart, and the gap is increasing.
A supplier can now deliver a dramatically more valuable outcome using a fraction of the effort they originally scoped. Under an effort-priced contract, that supplier is punished for the improvement - the customer captures the whole upside and then, at renewal, argues the price should come down because it’s obviously taking less work now.
If you have ever wondered why a supplier seems oddly reluctant to bring their best ideas and their automation to your account, that’s probably why. You have designed a contract in which their innovation is your saving and their loss. WorldCC’s 2019 research is direct about the fix: for long-term continuous cost reductions, split the benefit. It cites a 50/50 split, and notes that while radical, a split that even tells everyone the scheme is serious.
Ask yourself: Would you rather have 100% of theoretical gains that never materialize, or a supplier who continuously thinks about your situation and how they can help you improve it further to grow your business?
There is money in getting this right, not just virtue. WorldCC’s 2025 study with Icertis and the CCM Institute, Smarter Contracts, Better Margins,3 found that organizations with mature contract management capabilities typically identify cost savings and leakage recovery of 1–8% of total contract value, depending on complexity. The Value Gap report puts recoverable value at 2–3% of spend in year one and 5–10% over a three-year program.
What actually helps
- Do the discovery before the price, not after the signature. WorldCC’s Ten Pitfalls4 research identifies a lack of clear scope and goals as Pitfall 1 for a reason: it is the most frequent source of claims, disputes, and disrupted relationships, affecting around 40% of projects.
- Agree the problem/opportunity statement jointly and write it down. If both parties can’t state in a paragraph what they are trying to achieve and why it matters now, the scope schedule is guesswork dressed as precision, and you need to do more discovery.
- Offer discrete options rather than one negotiated scope. Three clearly differentiated options force an explicit conversation about what the customer is choosing not to buy and where they really see value. That conversation rarely happens when there is only one proposal on the table.
- Be specific about what is out of scope and don’t rely on assumptions. Allocate responsibility rather than listing caveats.
- Price the outcome where you can, and share the gain. But only alongside governance that will actually track whether the outcome arrived - otherwise you have just negotiated another clause destined to go inactivated.
Also, be careful what kind of change control you build. The Value Gap report is right that you need a defined process for how changes are requested, evaluated, priced and approved. But there is a difference between change control designed to price change quickly and fairly, and change control designed to make change so painful that nobody proposes any. The first protects and grows value. The second is how you end up with a supplier who has stopped bringing you ideas.
WorldCC’s Adaptive Contracting5 series puts the good version well. It suggests that a variation mechanism should initiate a controlled decision workflow rather than an ad hoc negotiation. A workflow processes change. A negotiation punishes it.
The same goes for the reflex to answer scope creep with more risk transfer. As the 2026 report puts it, allocating risk to a supplier through contract language does not mean the risk is managed. It determines who bears the consequences. Piling on risk transfer provisions prolongs negotiation, gets priced back to you, and still leaves you exposed when performance is poor. When performance is poor, it is still the customer who suffers.
Key questions to consider
- Of the seven leakage categories, which one is your scope creep story actually in? And are you about to fix one while ignoring six?
- Can you name a time your supplier delivered materially more value than they were paid for? What happened at the next renewal?
- Are there innovation, gain-share or continuous improvement clauses in your biggest contract right now? Does anyone in delivery know they exist? Do you need these clauses to force innovation, or could it happen more naturally?
Sources
- Closing the Procurement Value Gap (WorldCC / Ironclad, 2026)
- Supplier-Led Innovation and Continuous Improvement (IACCM, 2019)
- Smarter Contracts, Better Margins (WorldCC / CCM Institute / Icertis, 2025)
- The 10 Critical Pitfalls of Modern Contract Management (Tim Cummins, 2016; WorldCC members)
- Adaptive Contracting (WorldCC / Accenture, 2026)
If you'd like to talk through how any of this applies to your contracts, I'm always happy to have a conversation.
This post is part of a series on contract and commercial management I originally wrote for World Commerce & Contracting.



